Grant Heckenkemper谈客户出售企业时如何组建专业交易团队
The right thing to do when your client has an offer to sell their business
Grant Heckenkemper建议,客户收到企业出售要约后,应由长期CPA确认交易团队配置,并尽早引入具备私募股权收购经验的律师、税务结构顾问、卖方盈利质量专家和并购顾问。
I recently helped a client sell the family business he had run for more than 10 years to a private equity firm. As often happens with owners, my client thought he could use his longtime advisors on the transaction. I had to explain why that often isn't the best approach.
Processing Content
When I asked my client who the legal counsel would be, he told me he was going with his best friend, a retired, nonpracticing attorney. Why? Because the fee would only be $5,000.
I warned my client that his friend, the nonpracticing attorney, had never "papered" a PE-backed acquisition before. The kicker: His friend would only take calls before 7 a.m. before hitting the golf course.
As often happens, my client stayed with his buddy. "I don't want to run up legal fees," he told me without hesitation.
Fast forward several months. We're working toward closing, but my client's "buddy" isn't reachable. He was clearly overwhelmed by the length of the agreement and was haggling with the buyer over terms that are standard in a PE acquisition backed by a large bank. The deal eventually closed, but the delay and aggravation cost my client a lot more money than the discount legal fees saved him. Unfortunately, that's typical when business owners don't put the right people in the right seats on their deal team.
First rodeo vs. old hat
For most small to midsize family business owners, selling is a once-in-a-lifetime transaction. But it's far from the first rodeo for a PE buyer. The buyer doesn't have to scramble to assemble its deal team; they've used the same legal counsel on dozens, if not hundreds, of deals before. They have the same quality-of-earnings provider, and a savvy tax group that modeled the structure of the transaction multiple ways before approaching your client.
Here's where most sellers go wrong and leave their deal teams shorthanded:
After receiving an offer, owners naturally turn to the advisor they trust most. It's usually their attorney (if it seems like a legal matter) or their CPA who knows the company numbers inside and out. Unfortunately, owners often forget to tell their other advisors about the offer until much later. And their chosen advisor almost never says to the owner: "Here's who else we need on the team and when we should bring them in."
Start with the seats closest to you
Even if you've been your client's longtime CPA, "accountant" is not the only role on a deal team. If you are your client's incumbent/primary accountant, you are the steward of the business's institutional memory. Only you can answer why a position was taken in 2019, or why that reserve is sitting on the balance sheet, or which customer concentration is a contract, and which is a habit, etc.? No firm can replace that knowledge at any price. You are also responsible for providing clear, accurate financial records that stand through diligence, such as accrual-basis history a buyer will take without rebuilding it and add-back support written down when the money was spent rather than assembled in the second month of diligence. But that's not all.
A transaction tax structuring specialist should be brought in six to 12 months out, even earlier if a restructuring or qualified small business stock is involved. This is a different job from filing the tax returns, and where I most often see deals fall apart. Restructuring and QSBS eligibility both turn on entity type and on how long the stock has been held, and neither can be arranged in the final months before closing.
Sell-side quality-of-earnings expert. Ideally bring this specialist in 12 to 18 months out. He or she will run the numbers through the buyer's lens and build the add-back schedule that holds up during diligence. This role often has more impact on the deal value than any other. A well-defended add-back is worth a multiple of itself, and a rejected one costs more than it was ever worth.
The incumbent CPA seat is yours by default. The transaction tax structuring advisor and sell-side QoE expert are seats you'll likely fill with outside specialists – even if your client doesn't know those roles exist.
The remaining seats and timing
Here are other seats on the advisory table that good CPAs take time to fill well before closing:
- The transaction attorney should be hired and brought in 12 to 18 months before close. He or she designs the structure, papers the purchase agreement, negotiates indemnity, escrow and seller representations that there've been no instances of fraud, cybersecurity breaches in the last five years, or state tax audits, etc. The transaction attorney usually has a much better feel for market terms than your general business attorney.
- The M&A advisor should be brought in six to 12 months out. The M&A advisor builds a buyer list and runs a full marketing, solicitation and sale process through close. He or she also identifies buyers, handles marketing and solicitation of offers, execution of due diligence and closing. Competition for a deal is what moves the "number" in your client's favor. Don't let your client settle for the first offer that comes in. For smaller "Main Street" businesses, your client may only need a broker to list the business publicly and take a simpler approach to the valuation, terms and closing.
- Additional specialists should be added to the deal team three to six months out depending on your client's industry. Bring in an environmental specialist if there is industrial property involved in the transaction. Bring in benefits counsel if your client's company has a 401(k) or a professional employer organization for employees. Bring in IT and cyber specialists if your client holds customer data. And bring in separate counsel if your client owns their building personally and leases it to the business. This is something that's frequently overlooked in founder-led deals.
- For pre-liquidity planning, if your client doesn't already have one, you may want to bring in a wealth advisor with tax planning expertise before signing. He or she can advise on what happens to the sale proceeds, and create trusts and charitable structures that must be funded before a deal is binding.
What that means for you, the CPA
None of this makes you the general manager of your client's deal team. You are not picking the attorney and you shouldn't want to. But somebody must confirm who else is on the roster, and the person best positioned to do that is you — the one who heard about the deal first. Your client has trusted you with their numbers for years. When something this big happens, you are the one they call.
Clarifying these roles with your client costs you nothing, and it is worth more to him or her than anything you will produce once diligence is underway. When it comes to clients selling their business, you can't ever be accused of planning too far ahead.

Director of advisory services
Grant Heckenkemper, CPA, is director of advisory services at L&H CPAs & Advisors in Dallas, where he advises founder-led companies on mergers and... Read full bio
来源:Accounting Today(美国会计行业媒体) · accountingtoday.com