跳到正文
原文
香港会计及财务汇报局 · 新闻稿·· 21 天前精选站内评分68

香港会计及财务汇报局对Norton Rowland CPA Limited及项目董事罚款HK$196,000并限制执业18个月

AFRC fines Norton Rowland CPA Limited and its engagement director and imposes practice limitations for serious audit and assurance deficiencies in occupational retirement scheme engagements

导读

香港会计及财务汇报局公开训诫Norton Rowland及项目董事,分别罚款HK$98,000,合计HK$196,000,并施加18个月执业限制。执业限制期为2026年10月26日至2028年4月25日,项目董事Hung Chi Yuen, Andrew参与任何相关业务前还须完成指定领域的额外且可核验持续专业发展时数。

推荐理由

AFRC认定Norton Rowland及项目董事未获取充分适当审计证据,公开训诫、各罚HK$98,000并施加18个月执业限制。

正文

The Accounting and Financial Reporting Council (AFRC) has sanctioned Norton Rowland CPA Limited (Norton Rowland)1  and its engagement director, Mr Hung Chi Yuen, Andrew (Hung; together with Norton Rowland, the Regulatees)2  for serious deficiencies in statutory audit and assurance engagements relating to two occupational retirement schemes registered under the Occupational Retirement Schemes Ordinance (Cap. 426) (ORSO).

The AFRC has:

  • publicly reprimanded Norton Rowland and Hung;
  • imposed pecuniary penalties totalling HK$196,000, comprising HK$98,000 for each of Norton Rowland and Hung;
  • imposed practice limitations on Norton Rowland and Hung, requiring them not to accept, perform or participate in any audit or assurance engagements in respect of Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes and Occupational Retirement Schemes registered with the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority (Relevant Engagements) for a period of 18 months;3 and
  • imposed a direction that, before participating in any Relevant Engagements, Hung shall first undertake additional verifiable Continuing Professional Development hours on specified areas.

The AFRC’s Key Findings

The disciplinary action arose from an inspection of Norton Rowland covering the audits of the financial statements of and assurance work on compliance matters for two ORSO schemes for 2023, including one defined benefit scheme and one defined contribution scheme.  At the relevant time, the two schemes held substantial assets, with net assets available for benefits of approximately HK$1.4 billion and HK$59 million respectively.

The AFRC identified significant and pervasive deficiencies across both engagements.  In a number of key areas, including investments, benefits paid or payable to scheme members, and liabilities, the Regulatees failed to perform adequate procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence to support their audit opinions.  In particular, the Regulatees relied excessively on information obtained from those responsible for preparing the financial statements, including the trustee and actuary, without independently verifying key information underpinning the financial statements.  The deficiencies were not confined to isolated areas, but reflected a broader failure to understand the specialised requirements applicable to the audits of occupational retirement schemes.  

These deficiencies extended to the assurance work.  The Regulatees concluded that the schemes complied with prescribed ORSO requirements without performing adequate procedures to support those conclusions.  The assurance reports inappropriately used wording intended for Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes rather than Occupational Retirement Schemes, and omitted statements required under the ORSO.  Taken together, the deficiencies raised serious concerns over the Regulatees’ competence to undertake audit and assurance engagements for occupational retirement schemes.

Occupational retirement schemes are established to provide retirement benefits to scheme members.  The audits of their financial statements and the assurance work performed under the ORSO provide important independent scrutiny of both the financial position of the schemes and their compliance with statutory requirements.  Where auditors do not perform sufficient work before issuing their audit opinions and assurance conclusions, there is a risk that matters affecting scheme assets, obligations to members, or statutory compliance may remain undetected.

The AFRC’s Disciplinary Action

In determining the appropriate disciplinary sanctions, the AFRC considered all relevant circumstances, including the nature, seriousness, duration, frequency and impact of the misconduct.  The deficiencies were pervasive, extended across both engagements and involved retirement schemes holding substantial assets for the benefit of scheme members.  Whilst there was no evidence that the misconduct resulted in actual misstatements in the financial statements or statutory non-compliance, it increased the risk that such matters would remain undetected.  The AFRC also took into account the Regulatees’ degree of cooperation and full admission of misconduct in reducing their pecuniary penalties.

Ms Hester Leung, Head of Discipline, said, “Retirement scheme engagements are not routine compliance exercises, but provide important assurance over the schemes’ financial information and compliance with statutory requirements.  They require specialised expertise and a thorough understanding of the applicable regulatory framework.  This case demonstrates the risks that arise when auditors underestimate the complexity of such work.”

Ms Janey Lai, Chief Executive Officer, added, “Assurance engagements in respect of regulated entities play an important role in supporting effective regulation, maintaining public confidence and protecting the public interest.  Auditors carrying out such engagements must therefore exercise the necessary rigour and possess the requisite competence and expertise.  The AFRC will engage with other regulators where appropriate to ensure matters affecting the public interest are promptly identified and addressed.”

For details of the decision, please refer to the Statement of Disciplinary Action.

[1] Corporate practice registration number: S0374 (previously, M0374).

[2] Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants membership number: A09447.

[3] From 26 October 2026 to 25 April 2028.

来源:香港会计及财务汇报局 · 新闻稿 · afrc.org.hk

审计热点 是聚合摘要和阅读索引,原文版权归各来源所有,引用请以官方原文为准。如果你是来源方,希望更正、下架或调整展示方式,可以通过反馈页联系我们。

来自微信公众号的内容,本站仅呈现摘要与原文链接,不转载文章全文;文章权利归属原作者及原公众号

关于使用条款隐私信源