回顾 CPA 150小时教育要求
In Remembrance of the 150-Hour Educational Requirement
48个州已立法或实施允许以120学分加1年工作经验取得 CPA 资格的替代路径,150小时教育要求持续受到冲击。Utah State University 研究显示,学时要求变化与 CPA Exam 通过率、成绩无关联,额外教育提升会计毕业生质量亦无确凿证据。该要求源于1969年 Beamer Report。
Editor’s Note: This is the first in a new column authored by CPA Journal Editorial Advisory Board member Steven M. Mintz, a professor emeritus at California Polytechnic State University and author of the Ethics Sage blog (https://ethicssage.com). The column’s mission is to educate and inform accounting educators and professionals on issues of concern in accounting ethics and education. The editors hope readers will appreciate the column’s distinct perspective. While many things about business and accounting practice are in flux, CPAs’ commitment to upholding the highest standards of professional ethics remain essential.
The 150-hour educational requirement for licensure as a CPA has been under attack for a while now. One reason is that it creates a pipeline problem, whereby the education requirement serves as a barrier to entry for aspiring college graduates who seek to practice in the profession of accounting. The additional cost of education has kept many from completing the required 30 semester hours beyond the bachelor’s degree. The problem has been exacerbated by the fact that CPA firms have not, in general, supported the extra education by increasing the salaries of those who meet the 150-hour requirement.
In just a couple of years, most state boards of accountancy and legislatures have amended their laws in two important ways:
- Providing an alternative to the extra 30 semester hours by completing an extra year of work experience.
- Allowing accounting students to take the CPA Exam once they have completed 120 semester hours of education.
These changes have been referred to as the 120/150 bifurcated approach to accounting education. Minnesota has added a third option for licensure, including a master’s degree in accounting, plus 1 year of work experience, plus passing the CPA Exam (“Pathways to Becoming a CPA,” MNCPA, July 17, 2026, https://www.mncpa.org/involvement/legislative/broadening-pathways-to-cpa/national).
Taking the exam after graduating could conflict with the demands of early employment, but allowing students to take the CPA Exam after completing 120 hours of education, even if they have not yet graduated, provides the benefit of focused exam preparation students are already used to.
The question that remains is whether accounting students will still choose the 150-hour pathway to licensure. In this author’s view, it is likely that most students will choose a second year of experience instead of 30 extra hours of education because they can start to draw a salary sooner (an important consideration for students from lower income households). Many may not believe that the extra credits prepare them better for the CPA Exam. Moreover, there is no concrete proof that completion of the extra education increases the quality of the accounting graduate. The 120/150-unit bifurcated approach to accounting education is likely to be the path taken in most states. In fact, it has been reported that 48 states have enacted or implemented alternatives to the 150-hour requirement by allowing candidates to qualify with 120 credits and additional experience (B. Kolar, “CPA Requirements by State,” Atlas CPA Index, July 14, 2026, https://atlascpaindex.com/cpa-requirements).
Changes in CPA Exam Passing Rates
Professors from Utah State University collected data from 2006–2016 in order to examine the effect of the 150-hour requirement on first-time candidates sitting for the CPA Exam as well as candidate performance. Their findings indicated that a reduction in the number of credit hours required to sit for the exam increased the number of candidates, while an increase in the number of prerequisite hours reduced the number of candidates (E.F. Stephenson and B. Meehan, “Reducing a Barrier to Entry: The 120-150 CPA Licensing Rule,” Center for Growth and Opportunity at Utah State University, working paper, Jan. 7, 2021, https://tinyurl.com/5n72yk5r).

The Utah State authors found no relationship between changes in the CPA Exam requirements and passing rates or scores. They suggested that requiring 150 hours instead of 120 creates a potential barrier to entry for licensed CPAs with no accompanying increase in candidate quality. This may be why so many states have now amended their requirements to sanction the alternative of 120 credit hours to sit for the exam plus one additional year of work experience.
The Evolution of the 150-Hour Requirement
In 1967, a report sponsored by the Carnegie Corporation of New York, Horizons for a Profession: The Common Body of Knowledge for Certified Public Accountants, called for the accounting profession to join other learned professions—like medicine, law, and theology—in requiring graduate education (Robert H. Roy and James H. MacNeill, AICPA, 1967). In March 1969, the AICPA commissioned the Beamer Report, “Report of the Committee on Education and Experience Requirements for CPAs,” chaired by Elmer G. Beamer (https://egrove.olemiss.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1438&context=aicpa_comm). The report examined the educational requirements for accounting students who sought to become licensed CPAs. The most important recommendation in the report was that five years of college study was necessary to obtain the common body of knowledge required to enter the public accounting profession. Hence, the 150-hour requirement was born. The goal was to better equip CPAs to meet the requirements and needs of clients. The additional coursework would ensure that accounting professionals obtained a deeper understanding of accounting principles, business law, taxation, and emerging areas like technology and information systems.
In 1978, the AICPA issued Education Requirements for Entry into the Accounting Profession: A Statement of AICPA Policies, which stated that “at least 150 semester hours of college study are needed to obtain the common body of knowledge for CPAs and should be the educational requirement,” and that this education “should lead to the awarding of a graduate degree.” In reviewing model language for jurisdictions to use in implementing the 150-hour rule, the report stated: “While it could be implied that a 150-semester-hour program leads to a graduate degree, we believe that a graduate degree requirement should be explicitly stated” (https://egrove.olemiss.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1200&context=aicpa_guides).
In 1984, a committee of the American Accounting Association (AAA) recommended that university education for accountants include the following: 1) general education of two to four years; 2) general professional education of two years; and 3) specialized professional education (providing in-depth study in a functional area like auditing, taxation, or financial reporting) of one year. The committee envisioned that the specialized professional education should “frequently” lead to a graduate degree (N. M. Bedford and W.G. Shenkir, “Reorienting Accounting Education,” Journal of Accountancy, vol. 164, no. 2, pp. 84-91, August 1987).
During the 1980s, the AICPA recommended that state boards of accountancy adopt a 150-hour rule, and in January 1988, the AICPA membership approved (with an 83% majority) a requirement that applicants for membership after 2000 have 150 credit hours of education. In the wake of the membership vote, AICPA President Philip B. Chenok stated that “significant changes both in accounting and in the services demanded of CPAs have created a body of knowledge that can’t be assimilated in the normal undergraduate program” (“CPA Education Requirements: New Report Issued,” Journal of Accountancy, vol. 166 no. 4, p. 22, 1988).
The Treadway Report (Report of the National Commission on Fraudulent Financial Reporting, October 1987, https://tinyurl.com/te3s2ad4) was issued in 1987 following a stream of incidents of fraudulent financial reporting. The Treadway Commission Report identified the causes of and recommended solutions to the high incidence of fraudulent financial reporting in the United States during the 1970s and 1980s. It was established as a private sector initiative to improve internal controls, auditing standards, and corporate governance.
The Treadway Report focused attention on the need to sensitize students to business and accounting frauds that had occurred. The report discusses its findings following a series of financial frauds in the 1980s that shocked the business and investing communities. High profile financial frauds were investigated by Congress at companies such as ZZZZ Best, whose CEO, Barry Minkow, ran Ponzi schemes; fraud by investment advisors such as Ivan Boesky, who was involved with selling junk bonds to unsuspecting investors; and the failure of between 1,000-1,600 savings and loan institutions that cost $124-$160 billion.
The Treadway Report recommended teaching ethics to business students to make them aware of real and potential frauds and made recommendations for education in financial reporting and sound judgment. The report concluded that the accounting curriculum should integrate the development of ethical values with the acquisition of knowledge and skills to help prevent, detect, and deter fraudulent financial reporting. The commission recommended that the development of case studies based on actual situations be a priority to make students aware of the challenges in making ethical decisions. This was the first time that education in ethics was explicitly noted as a meaningful need for accounting education, and it seemed to fit nicely into the extra 30-hour requirement. Separate courses in business and accounting ethics started to appear at this time.
In 1988, the AICPA membership voted overwhelmingly to support the 150-hour requirement, recommending that states adopt it as a prerequisite for CPA licensure. The goal was designed to elevate accounting education to a level comparable to other professions—medicine and law—which required advanced education. It was also designed to enhance the CPA credential by ensuring candidates had a robust academic foundation.
The Public Interest
A Gallup Poll released on May 3, 2026, reported only 35% of stakeholders surveyed rate accountants very high or high for their honesty and ethics (https://tinyurl.com/2shyf58a). Accountants are ranked seventh out of 21 professions trailing all healthcare professions and teachers, and clustering near other mid-tier trust occupations. This is a reduction from past rankings. It could be attributable to the many frauds since the early 2000s (i.e., Enron and WorldCom), although the general decline in ethics for businesses probably created a spillover effect into rankings for accountants.
Digging deeper, the decline can be attributed to the following factors:
- Growth in non-audit services. This has created a clash of cultures between auditors, who must adhere to strict standards of ethics, including being completely independent of client management, whereas consultants and advisers are driven more by commercial factors.
- Increased pressure from CFOs and CEOs to report profits the way they want to instead of in accordance with GAAP.
- Challenges that result from expanding services in state-of-the-art fields such as technology, AI, and cryptocurrency.
- New equity forms of CPA firm ownership, creating various structures that reflect changes in business practices and regulatory environments, such as special-purpose acquisition companies (SPAC).
- Personal relationships within client managementcompromise objectivity and independence.
These factors raise questions about whether a traditional 120-hour education can adequately cover the skills needed for success in today and tomorrow’s accounting profession. The expanded scope of services was one of the reasons behind adding 30 hours to accounting education requirements. The question is whether the common body of knowledge has changed over the years. If the answer is it has expanded—and the author thinks most observers would agree—why should regulators make it significantly less likely that accounting students will complete 150-hours of education?
Accounting ethics should be considered an essential requirement for an accounting degree.
Is Accounting Still a Profession?
In November 2025, the US Department of Education announced that it is reclassifying accounting degrees as “non-professional.” This action came as a shock to many in the accounting community. “Classifying accountants as anything other than professionals fundamentally misrepresents the critical work CPAs perform, work that is responsible for the integrity of the global financial systems on which businesses and individuals rely,” said NASBA President and CEO Daniel J. Dustin, CPA. “There’s a reason certified public accountancy has been a licensed profession in the United States since 1896” (“NASBA Responds to Federal Reclassification of Accounting Degrees as ‘Non-Professional,’” NASBA, Nov. 25, 2025, https://nasba.org/blog/2025/11/25/nasba-responds-to-federal-reclassification-of-accounting-degrees-as-non-professional).
Within this context, it is reasonable to wonder whether state boards’ movement away from the 150-hour requirement influences the Department of Education’s move. The author would raise the question of whether the profession label no longer applies because of the commercial aspect of accounting services, and the tilt toward providing such services (i.e., consulting) rather than auditing services. Is it time to refer to accounting firms and practitioners as working in the accounting industry? Does the movement back to a 120-hour (non-graduate degree) requirement distance accounting from professions like medicine and law?
Where Should We Go from Here?
The National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) now recognizes three model pathways to becoming a CPA (https://tinyurl.com/2wdxdv8k):
- Graduate Degree Pathway: Graduate degree in accounting, one year of professional experience, and passing the CPA Exam.
- Traditional 150-Hour Pathway: Bachelor’s degree in accounting, 30 additional semester credits (total 150 semester hours), one year of experience, and passing the CPA Exam.
- New 120-Hour Pathway: Bachelor’s degree in accounting (120 semester hours), two years of professional experience, and passing the CPA Exam.
These options do not include the specific requirement for an accounting ethics course or other specific courses. In the author’s opinion, this was a mistake and one reason why the 150-hour requirement fell out of favor: It never specified what should be included in the extra 30 credits. A common joke among critics is that a student could take a course in basket weaving and it would count.
It could be that the renewed focus on 120 hours will effectively shut down Master of Accountancy programs. They are expensive to run, and they may experience a significant decline in enrollment due to the 120/150 alternative pathway. In this regard, it is up to accounting programs to reinvent their accounting education requirements. There may be courses that are included in a master’s program that should be considered as a requirement for the bachelor’s degree because of the evolving needs of the accounting profession. In this authors’ opinion, accounting ethics should be considered an essential requirement for an accounting degree. Of course, including an ethics course in the undergraduate curriculum may mean replacing another course, thus underlying the challenge facing faculty.
Steven M. Mintz, PhD, is a professor emeritus at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, Calif. He is a member of The CPA Journal Editorial Advisory Board.
The post In Remembrance of the 150-Hour Educational Requirement appeared first on The CPA Journal.
来源:The CPA Journal(美国 CPA 技术期刊) · cpajournal.com