跳到正文
原文
The CPA Journal(美国 CPA 技术期刊)· Tensie Whelan, OPM·· 2026-08-28精选站内评分58

Tensie Whelan 介绍 ROSI 框架量化可持续发展投入回报

Sustainability Accounting—Driving Better Returns Through Better Business

导读

Tensie Whelan 介绍 ROSI 五步法,评估机会与风险、识别实施策略、确定并量化收益、货币化收益,连接可持续发展战略与财务表现。

推荐理由

ROSI以五步法连接可持续发展战略与财务回报,步骤、指标和行业案例可供企业评估项目投入时参照。

正文

Corporate leaders and investors alike are faced with a growing list of financially material sustainability risks and opportunities. The manufacturing sector, for example, has significant water, energy, chemical, and labor risk embedded in its operations. The agricultural sector faces a similar set of challenges. The consumer goods sector has environmental and social risks to manage, as well as growing consumer demand for sustainable choices. Property and casualty insurance is reeling from climate-exacerbated disasters. Energy, real estate, automotive, and packaging are just a few of the industries being disrupted by the low carbon transition and customer demand.

Various regulatory regimes focused on sustainability—sometimes called environmental, social, and governance (ESG) reporting—have emerged as policy makers aim to require both improved corporate practices as well as disclosure of material risks and opportunities, with the most robust in the EU, but with many other countries (and California) strengthening their frameworks.

Many companies do not have robust ESG data to comply with such regulations. Such data has typically been collected by the sustainability team and housed in ad hoc formats. As executives and boards are beginning to be held responsible for their disclosures, a new position, that of ESG controller, has been created in many finance teams to put in place better controls and tracking of ESG data. A cross-business unit sustainability executive committee, including the CFO, and a stand-alone ESG committee at the board level has become de rigueur—89 of the Fortune 100 boards now have an ESG committee, for example (T. Whelan, “Research: Boards Still Have an ESG Expertise Gap—but They’re Improving,” Harvard Business Review, April 18, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/2knye6zu).

Reporting and disclosure make up the tip of the iceberg. Material sustainability issues must become embedded into the business strategy in order to drive better corporate financial performance, as well as better societal performance. Research finds that companies that manage material sustainability issues well can drive operational efficiency, innovation and growth, employee productivity and retention, customer sales and loyalty, and risk mitigation. Unfortunately, research also finds that most businesses have not set up the processes necessary to track the financial returns of their sustainability strategies. Even companies with sustainability embedded in their business strategy are not tracking related financial returns, except for some basic metrics such as energy savings or sales related to sustainable products.

Sustainability’s Role

CPAs can help with professionalizing the management of material nonfinancial data, such as greenhouse gas emissions, and integrate it with other reporting systems. CPAs can also improve corporate decision-making and reporting with better tracking of the financial returns associated with sustainability practices. The NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business (with which the author is affiliated) has researched how best to understand and track the intangible and tangible benefits of sustainability practices and developed a methodology called ROSI (Return on Sustainability Investment), which aims to support sustainability accounting and business leader decision-making (https://tinyurl.com/yhhhujmb).

The ROSI Methodology

The ROSI methodology aims to bridge the gap between sustainability strategies and financial performance, helping to build and track a better business case for both current and planned sustainability initiatives. As pictured in Exhibit 1, nine sustainability drivers of better financial performance emerge when sustainability is embedded in business strategy. Of course, any kind of good management can drive innovation, employment retention, or sales and marketing, but sustainability practices often drive several of these benefits, which can then be monetized.

EXHIBIT 1

Return on Sustainability Investment (ROSI) Framework

There are five steps to the ROSI process:

  • Step 1: Assess opportunities and risks. Identify the sustainability strategies that address the financially material ESG issues for the sector and the company, using IFRS/SASB as a guide. For example, an auto manufacturer’s strategy might be to improve waste management.
  • Step 2: Identify associated strategies. For each sustainability strategy, identify the most effective practices needed to implement the strategy. For example, a practice to improve waste management for automakers is to recycle paint and solvents.
  • Step 3: Determine expected benefits. Determine the potential and actual financial and societal benefits of these practices, through the lens of the mediating factors of financial performance (innovation, operational efficiency, supplier loyalty). For example, recycling paint and solvents reduces purchases, reduces waste disposal costs, and brings in revenue through the sale of excess recycled material.
  • Step 4: Quantify results of benefits. For example, identify the percentage of manufacturing waste that is recovered and reused.
  • Step 5: Monetize the benefits. Apply a monetization process to calculate monetary values for the intangible and tangible benefits. For example, weighted average unit cost of recovered materials versus the cost of reused materials and upfront investment, with the net being the return on investment.

Application of the ROSI methodology across sectors has demonstrated consistent financial results. For example, reducing energy, water, and waste is not only good for the environment, it also drives efficiencies and thus cost reductions. The examples that follow were all ROSI analysis by the NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business. One automotive company realized a net annual contribution of $235 million to EBIT as a result of their waste management strategies. By adopting a green chemistry approach which reduced water, energy, chemicals, waste, and greenhouse gas emissions, a pharmaceutical company realized $1.5 million in reduced (water use, waste disposal, carbon emission fees, and electricity) costs per 100 metric tons of product.

It’s not only operational efficiency—sustainability can also drive innovation and revenue growth. The Sustainable Market Share Index tracks annual purchasing of consumer packaged goods sold in the United States, (using Circana data) and found that products marketed as sustainable are growing nearly five times faster and comprise more than 25% of all consumer packaged goods products (see Exhibit 2).

EXHIBIT 2

Sustainable Market Share Index: Growth Rate

In another example, apparel companies Reformation and Eileen Fisher used ROSI and found that their circular product offerings (i.e., gently used clothing) brought in new customers, generated positive free media, and delivered high margin net returns of $1.8–1.9 million.

Sustainability is also an important value for retaining and motivating employees. REI, an activewear company, found through a ROSI analysis that its focus on purpose and sustainability was driving retention and productivity of $34 million annually (five percent of payroll). There are many other case studies that monetize the benefits of decarbonization, sustainable sourcing, sustainable packaging, water stewardship, and so on, across industries.

Challenges and Benefits

One challenge for sustainability accounting is the lack of robust, performance-oriented sustainability data (T. Whelan, “ESG Reports Aren’t a Replacement for Real Sustainability,” Harvard Business Review, July 27, 2022, https://tinyurl.com/p35e2rne). SASB metrics, for example, are primarily focused on outputs, e.g. whether a company has a policy rather than the outcome of that policy. But it is impossible to know whether a policy drives better performance without tracking the outcome. Improved sustainability reporting will require identifying and tracking key performance indicators (KPI) related to sustainability practices first, before assessing financial performance.

The following insights are based on the author’s research and direct engagement with corporate finance and sustainability leaders:

  • Sustainability is driving tangible and intangible financial value for companies. Sustainability KPIs and related ROSI KPIs need to be tracked to improve enterprise value.
  • For manufacturing and other sectors, CPAs require better tools to assess the embedded costs (e.g., water, carbon, waste), all of which are getting more expensive and volatile. An ESG controller or CSO can identify the finite resources and waste embedded in the company’s processes, and the finance team can monetize it.
  • Tangible value often is found in avoided costs (e.g. less energy, waste disposal, reusing components). The finance function should track these avoided costs in order to encourage further sustainability-linked operational efficiency benefits.
  • Intangible values, such as employee retention or risk mitigation, can be sizable, monetized, and part of an overall financial assessment.
  • People-oriented investments such as training are treated as costs, not investments; however, training in health and safety, for example, drives lower injury, lower insurance premiums, and higher productivity, so it should be treated as an investment.
  • Corporate commitments on sustainability are often not accompanied by a commitment to appropriate capital allocation and sustainability projects often cannot meet the internal hurdle rate. That internal hurdle rate, however, is often calculated without assessing the full value of financial benefits, such as avoided costs, avoided risks, productivity, and future sales benefits. The finance function can help leadership by developing a robust process to better assess returns on sustainability investments when assessing capital allocation requests.

Sustainability accounting—fully assessing the tangible and intangible financial benefits associated with sustainability strategies and practices—is an emerging field with limited tools and frameworks. The ROSI framework is an open-source methodology that provides a pathway. In addition, current financial and ESG accounting software solutions do not integrate financial performance with sustainability performance. There too, new products and services are needed. In a world with limited natural resources and growing societal challenges, accountants can help corporate leadership make better decisions that improve enterprise and societal value.

Tensie Whelan is the founding director of the Center for Sustainable Business and distinguished professor of practice emerita, business and society, at the NYU Stern School of Business.

The post Sustainability Accounting—Driving Better Returns Through Better Business appeared first on The CPA Journal.

来源:The CPA Journal(美国 CPA 技术期刊) · cpajournal.com

审计热点 是聚合摘要和阅读索引,原文版权归各来源所有,引用请以官方原文为准。如果你是来源方,希望更正、下架或调整展示方式,可以通过反馈页联系我们。

来自微信公众号的内容,本站仅呈现摘要与原文链接,不转载文章全文;文章权利归属原作者及原公众号

关于使用条款隐私信源