《CHIPS 法案的 GAAP 缺口:FASB 以 ASU 2025-10 补救,但为时已晚》
The CHIPS Act's GAAP gap: FASB's fix arrives too late to help
美国《CHIPS 法案》投入 2,800 亿美元联邦补助,但美国 GAAP 长期仅有 ASC 832 要求附注说明,缺乏确认、分类与列报规则,三星、台积电、美光等受赠企业分别套用 IAS 20、ASC 958-605、ASC 450 三种框架处理。FASB 于 2025 年 12 月发布 ASU 2025-10 统一处理并要求披露所选政策,但强制生效时点尚未到达,对现行安排为时已晚。

I-Hwa Cheng/Bloomberg
The Creating Helpful Incentives to Produce Semiconductors and Science Act of 2022, or CHIPS Act, has put $280 billion in federal grants behind a new generation of U.S. semiconductor fabs, and the money comes with the same conditions and guardrails no matter who receives it. But two companies that receive an economically identical CHIPS Act grant — one reporting under U.S. GAAP, one under IFRS — can end up presenting that grant in almost unrecognizable ways.
Processing Content
For practitioners advising any company in the semiconductor supply chain, that's a live problem right now, not a hypothetical one.
International recipients report under IFRS, where IAS 20 has governed government grant accounting since 1983. It's a specific, three-part standard: Recognition requires reasonable assurance that conditions will be met and the funds will be received; classification separates asset-related grants (ties to a fab or other long-term asset) from income-related grants (tied to operating costs); and presentation offers two visible options for each category.
Samsung's up to $6.4 billion award for its Taylor, Texas, project and TSMC's up to $6.6 billion for three Arizona fabs both fall under IAS 20, since both companies report under IFRS. The Commerce Department has tied funding for both awards to project milestones — construction, tool installation, and production targets — which lines up with IAS 20's reasonable-assurance trigger: The grant is recognized as those milestones are met, not when the award is announced
U.S. companies had no equivalent standard to reach for. The only guidance on the books, ASC 832, required a company to describe the grant it received in a footnote — nothing about how to recognize, classify or present it. That gap sent preparers looking for an analogy, and they didn't all pick the same one.
Three ways preparers have filled the gap
Before ASU 2025-10, domestic CHIPS Act recipients have generally reached for one of three frameworks:
1. IAS 20 analogy. This is the most common route for larger companies with international operations, per Big Four firm EY's technical guidance on CHIPS Act accounting. It comes in two flavors: reducing the carrying amount of the asset, with the benefit surfacing as lower depreciation, or booking the grant as deferred income, with a visible grant-income line each period.
Micron, which received a $6.1 billion award for fab construction in Idaho and New York, disclosed in its 10-K that its government incentives are conditioned on construction and production milestones and remain subject to reduction, termination or clawback — but its filings do not identify by name which of the two IAS 20-style presentation options it applies.
2. ASC 958-605 analogy. Borrowed from not-for-profit accounting, this treats the grant as contribution revenue and requires all performance barriers to be substantially overcome before recognition — a stricter bar than IAS 20's reasonable-assurance standard.
3. ASC 450 analogy (contingent gains). The most conservative approach, this treats the grant as a contingent gain recognized only when virtually certain. Coherent Corp., which signed a letter of intent for up to $50 million toward its Sherman, Texas, indium phosphide fab expansion, remains at the letter-of-intent stage, with final terms to still be negotiated — exactly the fact pattern this conservative approach is built for. A company that is far from a signed award would typically book nothing yet; its future filings will show which framework it actually applies once the agreement is finalized.
All three are permissible under current guidance. None of them has to be named. ASC 832 only requires a description of the grant received, not a citation to the framework a company is borrowing from.
The part that should worry practitioners: clawback
The CHIPS Act guardrails carry substantial legal and financial consequences. Non-compliance — including missed production milestones, technology offshoring, or unmet domestic workforce commitments — can mandate full or partial repayment of federal funds.
Micron's own 10-K makes the point directly: Its government incentives are "subject to reduction, termination, or clawback," and failure to hit milestones "could result in up to all of certain incentives being clawed back, in some cases along with interest and/or loss of project assets."
Under IAS 20, how that repayment hits the income statement depends entirely on which presentation method was used going in: A company using the deferred income method absorbs repayment against the remaining liability first, while a company using the net asset method simply depreciates a higher carrying value over time, with no separate hit visible at all. The same asymmetry exists on the U.S. GAAP side, multiplied by three possible starting frameworks instead of two.
An investor, auditor or lender comparing exposure across a portfolio of CHIPS Act recipients isn't just comparing different numbers. They're comparing different accounting architectures, with no disclosure requirement flagging that the difference even exists.
ASU 2025-10 fixed this — starting in 2029
FASB addressed this gap in December 2025 with ASU 2025-10, "Government Grants (Topic 832): Accounting for Government Grants Received by Business Entities." It establishes one recognition threshold based on probability, adopts the same asset-related/income-related classification IAS 20 already uses, resolves the forgivable-loan question by treating forgiveness-probable loans as grants from the start, and — critically for the comparability problem — requires companies to disclose which accounting policy they chose.
One wrinkle survives: ASU 2025-10's "probable" threshold is a touch stricter than IAS 20's "reasonable assurance," so a small timing gap between U.S. GAAP and IFRS recognition will remain even after adoption.
The bigger issue is timing. ASU 2025-10 isn't mandatory until fiscal years beginning after Dec. 15, 2028. Early adoption is allowed but not required. That means the entire construction phase of the current wave of CHIPS Act fabs — the phase generating the largest grant-related numbers — will already be reported, audited and evaluated under the old, ungoverned system before the new standard applies to anyone who doesn't elect in early.
What this means for clients now
For a firm with a CHIPS Act recipient as a client, the near-term to-do list is straightforward: Identify which analogous framework the client is actually applying, even if the 10-K never names it; confirm that choice is documented and applied consistently; and flag now, well before 2029, whether early adoption of ASU 2025-10 would tell a cleaner story to investors, lenders, or the client's own audit committee. Clawback exposure should be modeled against the client's existing method, not assumed away, since a guardrail violation years from now will be measured against a policy chosen today.
FASB got the standard right. The CHIPS Act just didn't wait for it. Until 2029 catches up with the accounting, the job of making these numbers comparable falls to practitioners — because right now, nothing in the rules requires anyone else to do it.

Private equity associate
Mark Asprer, CPA, is a private equity associate at Triple Peak Capital where he leads technical accounting and quality of earnings work with a focus... Read full bio
来源:Accounting Today(美国会计行业媒体) · accountingtoday.com