Robert M. Cornell提出以过程与结果问责应对人工智能对会计职业的冲击
From Disruption to Discipline
Robert M. Cornell提出以过程问责与结果问责相结合,应对人工智能对会计教育与会计职业的冲击。过程问责要求说明AI如何用于工作及决策过程,结果问责关注最终成果;文章建议结合两者,披露AI使用、调整评分规则并加强培训与校企协作。作者认为,AI可用于预测性审计模型、自动化重复任务和欺诈检测等场景,但应用时需维护专业判断、学术诚信、透明度与伦理责任。
IN BRIEF
Artificial intelligence (AI) is already transforming accounting practice and education; CPAs need to learn how to adapt in this new environment and capitalize upon the opportunities it presents. This article suggests professionals and educators take a collaborative approach that is open to future innovation while centering the human values that maintain the public’s trust in the profession. It recommends a collaborative application of process and outcome accountability to help align educational and professional objectives.
***
Accounting education and the accounting profession are at a defining inflection point. Artificial intelligence (AI) is no longer a distant prospect; it is actively reshaping professional practice and redefining how to prepare the next generation of accountants. The key to professional success will be cultivating an awareness of AI as it rapidly evolves—one whose benefits, risks, and limitations require continuous reassessment and shared learning for effective use in accounting.
A wide range of professional services are rapidly adopting AI, provoking concern about workforce displacement and job security (D. Cubbins, “Fiverr CEO Warns of AI Job Displacement as Zuckerberg Eyes AI for Meta’s Coding Future,” Tech-Issues Today, May 7, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/ykf3mpef; L. Varanasi, “Hamilton, Inside the AI Boom that’s Transforming How Consultants Work at McKinsey, BCG, and Deloitte,” Business Insider, April 27, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/4wdexcmr). The central question is no longer whether AI will alter the accounting profession—it already has—but how the profession can harness this technology in ways that elevate, rather than erode, the competencies that define accounting excellence: deep expertise, critical skepticism, and sound professional judgment. These elements of excellence will become more important as the use of AI increases, coupled with other changes, such as reductions to human capital.
For the accounting profession to thrive in an AI-augmented future, educators and practitioners must pivot from apprehension to strategic adoption. AI need not be a threat to professional knowledge but can be a force multiplier for accounting quality and efficiency. Embracing this shift requires a clear-eyed assessment of how AI can support core functions and enhance decision making while keeping in mind its limitations and potential for misuse. Although AI tools are not universally effective and can fail under certain conditions, current trends suggest that AI will occupy a central role in the future of work broadly, and accounting specifically (C. Ashayeri, “When Not to Use AI: A Realist’s Guide,” Substack, March 29, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/3hw3pbxw; B. Edwards, “AI Search Engines Cite Incorrect News Sources at an Alarming 60% Rate, Study Says,” Ars Technica, March 13, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/yeyruc58; Harvard Business Review, “Managing the Future of Work: Microsoft’s AI Perspective,” HBR IdeaCast [Audio Podcast Episode], 2025, https://tinyurl.com/49fc53ev; M. H. Jarrahi, “Artificial Intelligence and the Future of Work: Human-AI Symbiosis in Organizational Decision Making,” Business Horizons, vol. 61, no. 4, pp. 577–586, 2018, https://tinyurl.com/4fm79ctu; B. Oliver, “How Artificial Intelligence Can Help Save Accounting,” Journal of Accountancy, Nov. 15, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/2bnvrba9).
The educational landscape reflects a parallel tension. Faculty across institutions increasingly recognize that the profession is undergoing rapid evolution, and today’s students must enter the workforce equipped with innovative skills, analytical agility, and practical experience in AI-enhanced environments. Accounting educators are concerned about the growing misuse of AI to circumvent meaningful learning, but the mastery of technical accounting and AI integration will increasingly be expected of college graduates. This challenge has expanded rapidly, with commentators noting that “rampant AI cheating is ruining education” and warning that “ChatGPT has unraveled the entire academic project” (J. D. Walsh, “Everyone Is Cheating Their Way Through College: ChatGPT has Unraveled The Entire Academic Project,” New York Magazine, May 7, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/mwnuutzs). This issue is not only widespread, but deeply disruptive to pedagogical integrity (M. Barnum and D. Seetharaman, “There’s a Good Chance Your Kid Uses AI to Cheat,” Wall Street Journal, March 15, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/rweefh8t). This disruption also presents a profound opportunity, much like the advent of the internet several decades ago (S. Stein Smith, “Integrating Emerging Technologies into Accounting Education,” New Jersey Society of CPAs, Oct. 31, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/27cers72; R. Tandiono, “The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on Accounting Education: A Review of Literature,” E3S Web of Conferences, vol. 426, no. 02016, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/3wxmptzr).

Educators now face a transformative moment to redesign learning experiences that integrate AI as a tool for critical thinking, data analysis, and professional judgment, rather than as a shortcut. Simultaneously, leading accounting firms are documenting and sharing their experiences using AI across diverse applications (Deloitte AI Institute, “Deloitte AI Institute: Benefits and limitations of Generative AI,” Deloitte Development, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/yw8cu4u3; “Will You Shape the Future of AI, or Will It Shape You?” EY, https://tinyurl.com/3dj5h985; A. Kenney, “Generative AI’s Toughest Question: What’s It Worth?” Journal of Accountancy. Feb. 1, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/fmese2es; Thomson Reuters Tax & Accounting, “How Do Different Accounting Firms Use AI?” Thomson Reuters Tax & Accounting Blog, June 3, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/37y3ra5w). These early adopters offer practical insights into how AI can streamline operations, enhance service delivery, and support complex analyses.
There is an opportunity for accounting firms, faculty, and students to engage in meaningful collaboration. Through this collaboration, the profession can build a future in which AI serves as a catalyst for innovation while safeguarding the human-centered values that sustain public trust. Now is the time to lean into the transformative power of AI—not only to preserve the integrity of accounting education and the accounting profession, but to elevate CPAs’ capacity for creating value, delivering critical insight, and contributing to society.
Confronting AI Risks
Accounting education must confront the series of AI risks head-on. Foremost among these is the issue of academic integrity—ensuring that student submissions genuinely reflect individual understanding and effort (A. M. Abdo-Salloum and H. Y. Al-Mousawi, “Accounting Students’ Technology Readiness, Perceptions, and Digital Competence Toward Artificial Intelligence Adoption in Accounting Curricula,” Journal of Accounting Education, vol. 70, no. 100951, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/3sjybvxd; D. Thody, “AI’s Impact on Accountancy Education: A Student’s Perspective,” International Federation of Accountants, Aug. 7, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/775fe7we). Beyond this, AI threatens to displace, rather than develop, the critical thinking skills essential to professional judgment. Recent research documents a troubling decline in reasoning and problem-solving abilities among young adults, and these trends are especially problematic in accounting, where precision, skepticism, and ethical discernment are paramount (“PISA and PIAAC 2025 Results: Trends in Reasoning and Skills,” Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, 2025).
The New Standard for Graduate Readiness
Both educators and employers share the goal of well-prepared accounting graduates. Stakeholders emphasize the importance of durable, human-centered skills—critical thinking, communication, resilience, and ethical leadership—alongside technical and technological (e.g., AI) fluency. Experiential learning, microcredentials, and interdisciplinary programs are emerging as essential tools for preparing students for dynamic, lifelong careers in an increasingly complex and unpredictable global marketplace (AACSB, 2025 State of Business Education Report, p.3, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/5dsjj366).
Students who depend too heavily on AI for tasks such as tax computations, depreciation schedules, or financial statement analysis risk losing their independent critical thinking skills. Without structured learning experiences that demand analytical engagement, students will become passive recipients of AI-generated output and thus be ill-prepared to detect inaccuracies or respond effectively to novel or ambiguous situations. Without deliberate ethical instruction, students may normalize the use of AI as a substitute for professional reasoning, both in academic settings and eventually in practice.
The most profound danger lies in the erosion of the educational foundation that underpins technical competence, problem-solving ability, and ethical responsibility. If AI is allowed to serve primarily as a shortcut, then the profession will find a cohort of graduates ill-equipped to confront the evolving demands of the field.
Rejecting AI altogether is not viable, as the power of AI in accounting classrooms and practice cannot be ignored. The accounting profession must prioritize a dual objective: understanding how to deploy AI responsibly and designing systems to evaluate its use effectively. This includes developing pedagogical and assessment strategies that promote meaningful learning, and professional norms that emphasize human judgment and ethical accountability. Through this approach, accounting educators and practitioners can ensure that AI supports, rather than supplants, students’ preparation for the profession.
Applying Process and Outcome Accountability to AI
Insights from decades of research on process and outcome accountability can help guide the effective implementation and oversight of AI in accounting education and professional practice. Drawing from the disciplines of social psychology, organizational behavior, and decision making, this research provides a critical lens through which AI-enabled work can be evaluated and improved.
Process accountability refers to the obligation to explain the steps, logic, and reasoning behind decisions and actions taken to reach a result (P. E. Tetlock, “Accountability: The Neglected Social Context of Judgment and Choice,” Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 7, pp.297–332, 1985). This form of accountability assumes particular significance in AI-integrated environments, as it encourages thoughtful engagement, discourages reliance on cognitive shortcuts, and promotes transparency. Individuals who anticipate being asked to justify their methods tend to adopt more deliberate and rigorous approaches to their work (J. S. Lerner and P. E. Tetlock, “Accounting for the Effects of Accountability,” Psychological Bulletin, vol. 125, no. 2, pp.255–275, 1999, https://tinyurl.com/bddknzu3).
In contrast, outcome accountability evaluates performance solely based on end results—such as test scores, client deliverables, or final reports—without consideration for how those outcomes were produced. While this approach can incentivize efficiency and high performance in certain contexts, it also introduces significant risks. When outcomes are easily outsourced, as with the use of AI tools, there is increased potential for superficial engagement, corner-cutting, and even deception (P. E. Tetlock, L. Skitka, and R. Boettger, “Social and Cognitive Strategies for Coping with Accountability: Conformity, Complexity, and Bolstering,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, vol.57, no.4, pp.632–640, 1989, https://tinyurl.com/37eyy3nd).
Empirical research has examined how different accountability structures influence reasoning quality, ethical standards, and professional conduct. Studies have demonstrated that when individuals expect to be held accountable for their reasoning processes, they exhibit deeper critical thinking, heightened self-scrutiny, and more integrative problem-solving (I. Simonson and P. Nye, “The Effect of Accountability on Susceptibility to Decision Errors,” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, vol.51, no.3, pp.416–446, 1992, https://tinyurl.com/cm7xwe4e). Conversely, when evaluations focus exclusively on outcomes, individuals could prioritize appearance over substance, seek to avoid blame, or engage in ethically questionable behaviors in order to meet performance benchmarks.
The Accountability Advantage in an AI World
What drives ethical AI use in accounting?
- Process accountability cultivates critical thinking, ethical judgment, and transparency.
- Outcome accountability drives performance and focus—but without process safeguards, a focus on outcomes can incentivize shortcuts.
- Blending both process and outcomes creates a resilient framework that promotes meaningful learning and professional integrity in AI-enhanced environments.
The future of accounting belongs to those who can clearly explain not just what they did but how they did it.
The relevance of these accountability models extends across multiple domains, including educational psychology, business ethics, behavioral economics, and accounting. In educational contexts, process accountability supports the development of durable learning, ethical discernment, and performance under conditions of uncertainty. In contrast, outcome accountability may contribute to surface-level learning, performance anxiety, and heightened vulnerability to manipulation—of particular concern in environments where AI can obscure the origins of work products.
Implementing a Blended Outcome and Process Accountability Framework
As accounting programs and professional service firms incorporate AI into their workflows, the accountability framework becomes even more consequential. Overreliance on outcome-based evaluation risks rewarding AI-generated deliverables that lack human judgment or ethical rigor. To guard against this, academic and professional systems must prioritize process accountability by requiring individuals to articulate how AI was used, how decisions were made, and how the resulting work aligns with professional and ethical standards.
When faculty evaluate only final deliverables without examining the cognitive effort underlying them, it is possible that students have used tools like ChatGPT or other AI systems to make the grade without achieving actual learning or comprehension (D. A. Wood, et al., “The ChatGPT Artificial Intelligence Chatbot: How Well Does It Answer Accounting Assessment Questions?” Issues in Accounting Education, vol.38, no.4, pp.81–108, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/ydab49x3). By placing equal or greater emphasis on how students complete their work, instructors can better promote ethical behavior, student engagement, and the development of professional competencies. Such a framework would encourage students to document their reasoning, reflect on their decision-making, and show mastery beyond delivering a final product.
The development of a balanced accountability approach begins with a clear and consistently communicated policy framework. Students must receive transparent guidance on permitted versus restricted uses of AI. For example, instructors may allow AI tools to support brainstorming or initial research but restrict their use for working on final deliverables. Rubrics must be adapted to reflect this blended framework, incorporating both product quality and the processes by which the work was generated. Use of frequent, meaningful communication and feedback further reinforce expectations and create a shared understanding of responsible AI use.
The overreliance on AI via human cognitive offloading can cause something known as “workslop.” Workslop is AI-generated work that lacks substance and is often incorrect (K. Niederhoffer, et al., “AI-generated ‘Workslop’ Is Destroying Productivity,” Harvard Business Review, Sep. 25, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/4jw4yn69). Aside from eroding collaboration, trust, and overall workplace effectiveness, a misplaced reliance on AI undermines productivity and creativity. This is because workslop shifts cognitive labor from meaningful problem-solving to supervisor and peer review, rework, and error management—a hidden workload of correcting AI-generated output.
To ensure that learning outcomes remain central, outcome accountability should be preserved in a more nuanced manner. Evaluation rubrics should emphasize clarity, originality, critical thinking, and synthesis, rather than relying solely on the final deliverable. Although current AI detection tools, such as Turnitin’s AI checker or GPTZero, remain imperfect, they may eventually offer more reliable indicators of AI-generated content. Nonetheless, faculty should adhere to standardized procedures for documenting suspected academic misconduct.
Rethinking Assessment in the Age of AI
Accounting faculty and CPA firms should be able to answer the following questions:
- Are students and employees developing critical thinking and ethical reasoning throughout their work, or merely submitting AI-generated results?
- How is AI use being documented, reflected upon, and justified?
- What are the legal and ethical guidelines for documenting and disclosing AI support in work products?
- What processes, controls, and safeguards are in place to ensure AI tools amplify—not replace—human expertise?
Redesigning assessments around a combination of process and outcome accountability will lead to professionals who can use AI responsibly and impactfully.
Overall, the success of this blended accountability framework depends on effective training and support for both students and faculty. Students benefit from orientation workshops that provide practical guidance on ethical and effective AI use. Faculty development efforts should focus on creating enforceable AI policies, identifying AI-generated work, and designing AI-resilient assignments. Through this framework, accounting educators can uphold the values of transparency, integrity, and intellectual rigor while adapting to a future in which AI will be an integral part of academic and professional life. The blended model not only safeguards against academic misconduct, but it also fosters the skills and ethical discernment that students need in their careers.
Collaborative Learning and Accountability
As AI becomes deeply embedded within both educational and professional environments, its effective implementation increasingly depends on intentional design, iterative adaptation, and robust accountability structures (J. A. Ballantine, G. Boyce, and G. Stoner, “A Critical Review of AI in Accounting Education: Threat and Opportunity,” Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 99 (102711), 2024, https://tinyurl.com/bbnbd67t). While faculty have adapted academic assignments and assessments to incorporate process and outcome accountability, parallel innovations are necessary in professional practice. Mutual learning between academia and practice can foster stronger, more ethically grounded AI applications.
Although global accounting firms have adopted specialized AI tools to enhance service delivery and internal operations, substantial opportunity remains for collaboration among students, faculty, and accounting professionals, particularly within small- and medium-sized organizations. These stakeholder groups stand to benefit from partnerships that bridge the gap between academic instruction and real-world application (B. Strickland, “Gravitating to Gen AI: CPA Leaders Show Increased Interest,” Journal of Accountancy, Dec. 12, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/yeyufb8k). At the center of such efforts must be a balanced framework of process and outcome accountability—a model that ensures AI tools are not only technically effective but also ethically sound, contextually appropriate, and educationally meaningful.
Collaborative learning frameworks that embrace this dual accountability model are especially well-suited for projects where innovation and professional growth occur simultaneously. Projects might involve co-authoring regulatory comment letters or developing case studies that examine the legal, ethical, and compliance dimensions of AI use in accounting (C. A. Botosan, M. S. Hill, and G. K. Taylor, “Engaging Students in the Standard Setting Process,” Issues in Accounting Education, vol. 39, no.1, pp. 47–68, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/hasmn73u). Such initiatives provide fertile ground for practical experimentation, reflection, and evaluation.
The outputs generated through these collaborations hold both functional and reputational value. Deliverables such as white papers, peer-reviewed journal articles, regulatory submissions, and prototype tools not only reflect technical expertise, but also serve as case studies in accountability, enabling evaluation of both the processes used and the outcomes achieved. Through this lens, educators and professionals can assess project effectiveness, extract best practices, and inform future initiatives across educational and professional boundaries.
Embedding process accountability within the project infrastructure itself is essential. Tools such as reflective learning logs, archives of AI prompts and responses, and peer evaluation systems ensure that participants are not only producing outputs but also engaging thoughtfully with the methods and decisions that underpin their work. In this way, process accountability promotes critical engagement with AI rather than passive reliance. It reinforces technical fluency, supports ethical reasoning, and fosters problem-solving capacities that are vital to long-term success.
The sustainability of these collaborative efforts depends upon the careful alignment of incentives. Professionals benefit from exposure to new technologies, opportunities for mentorship, and access to emerging ideas and talent. Students enhance their employability by gaining practical experience, building networks, and developing marketable skills. Faculty enrich their pedagogy, advance their research agendas, and cultivate deeper connections with industry partners (S. Ankrah and O. AL-Tabbaa, “Universities–Industry Collaboration: A Systematic Review,” Scandinavian Journal of Management, vol.31, no.3, pp.387-408, 2015, https://tinyurl.com/kestxb9r). Accountability mechanisms—including detailed rubrics, structured review templates, and standardized feedback forms—not only support individual development, but they also enable broader evaluation of the collaborative model’s effectiveness and impact.
Collaboration is the Competitive Edge
The future of accounting requires partnerships. The most transformative AI initiatives will be co-created in collaborative endeavors:
- Students bring innovative insights, curiosity, work ethic, and agility.
- Faculty offer pedagogical frameworks, analytical expertise, and grounding in foundational research.
- Professionals contribute applied insights, mentorship, and real-world complexity.
By fostering a culture of shared responsibility and continuous learning, this framework offers a path forward for integrating AI into accounting in a way that is both innovative and principled. The collaborative application of process and outcome accountability ensures that educational and professional objectives remain aligned, and that AI serves as a catalyst for excellence rather than a shortcut to expedience.
Exploring AI Opportunities Together
AI possesses vast potential to address challenges within the accounting profession. From enabling predictive audit models to automating repetitive tasks to generating accessible explanations of complex issues, AI can free professionals to engage more deeply with clients, exercise strategic judgment, and ultimately add more value. The goal is not merely increased efficiency, but an enhancement of professional focus—to a focus of high-impact, intellectually demanding, and ethically grounded work.
The true promise of AI does not rest solely in its capacity to automate tasks, but in its power to augment human expertise, amplify analytical insight, and create more meaningful professional experiences (J. Khakurel and K. Blomqvist, “Artificial Intelligence Augmenting Human Teams. A Systematic Literature Review on the Opportunities and Concerns,” in H. Degen, S. Ntoa, (eds.). Artificial Intelligence in HCI, HCII 2022, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 13336, 2022, https://tinyurl.com/5868t6be). Together, students, faculty, and practitioners can harness AI for innovation, whether to develop advanced fraud detection tools, optimize financial decision-making, clarify complex analyses, automate repetitive tasks, search for anomalies in complex data, or tailor communications for diverse audiences.
Robert M. Cornell, PhD, CMA, is an associate professor of accounting at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas.
Rick C. Warne, PhD, CPA, CFE, is an accounting and litigation consultant.
The post From Disruption to Discipline appeared first on The CPA Journal.
来源:The CPA Journal(美国 CPA 技术期刊) · cpajournal.com