跳到正文
原文
Accounting Today(美国会计行业媒体)· Leo Unzeitig·· 20 天前站内评分39

Leo Unzeitig分析美国国内税收法典第180条剩余肥料扣除争议

Digging into the fertility deduction

导读

作者Leo Unzeitig分析美国国内税收法典第180条在农场出售后针对剩余肥料的扣除问题,并援引IRS技术意见备忘录9211007说明买方的申报路径。他建议在交易前取得卖方施肥记录、安排同期土壤取样并由农艺师估值,在购买协议中约定剩余肥料金额,同时处理买卖双方税务处理的一致性。

正文

The first time that a client comes into your office and asks you whether they can take a "fertility deduction," I imagine your reaction will be the same as mine: a long pause followed by thoughts about babies and perhaps IVF.

Processing Content

But you'd be wrong. The taxpayer is most certainly referencing Section 180. That humble provision has been in the Code since 1960. It lets farmers take a deduction for purchasing fertilizer. And that's not particularly novel, but it has spawned some interesting questions lately. 

While everyone calls it the "fertilizer deduction," that shorthand actually understates the statute. Section 180(a) applies to expenditures for the purchase or acquisition of: "fertilizer, lime, ground limestone, marl, or other materials to enrich, neutralize or condition land used in farming." But for simplicity, we will limit the analysis to fertilizer and farming for purposes of this article.

Section 180 dates back to a time when farmers were purchasing fertilizer for farms that typically had a benefit that was useful for more than one year. The IRS had successfully taken the position that fertilizer used over more than one year needed to be capitalized and amortized over the useful life of the product. Thus, if Farmer Joe bought $300,000 of fertilizer and it was used equally over three annual growing seasons, he was limited to taking a deduction of $100,000 per year.

Congress, looking to help farmers like Joe, created Section 180 to allow them to elect to deduct the entire cost in the year of purchase.

Again, simple enough.

But what happens when Farmer Joe buys $300,000 of fertilizer in year one, but then sells his farm to Farmer Bob in year two right before the second growing season starts? 

Farmer Bob is arguably buying land which has $200,000 of "residual" fertilizer left to use. Thus, if the sales price was $1 million, Farmer Bob might argue that only $800,000 must be capitalized into nondepreciable land and $200k can be immediately deducted as a Section 180 fertilizer expense.

That argument was raised by the taxpayer in IRS Technical Advice Memorandum 9211007. While the IRS ultimately disagreed with the taxpayer in that case because of some unusual facts regarding (among other things) ownership of the land, it suggested that under the right facts and circumstances, Farmer Bob probably could deduct the portion of the purchase price allocable to the residual fertilizer.

And that's where the rubber meets the road: What are the "right facts and circumstances"?

Well first, taxpayers would probably need to be able to establish that the seller of the farm did indeed purchase fertilizer or other qualifying soil-conditioning materials to the property. It's often hard to do that because buyers don't necessarily have access to the seller's books and records, but one can probably infer whether that was done based on the prior land operations. If it's obvious there were crops and the seller had farming equipment, you're probably safe here. 

But if the land is scrub brush and looks like it hasn't been touched in years, it becomes more difficult to assume fertilizer was applied (much less that any residual amount is left). If there is an audit, the IRS might have the ability to look to the seller's prior returns and review their Schedule F, which has a dedicated line item for "Fertilizers and lime." Unfortunately, buyers don't have the same ability to verify that. That makes obtaining information from the seller before closing particularly valuable.

Assuming you have a reasonable basis to conclude the prior owner added fertilizer or incurred expense to "enrich, neutralize, or condition" the land, the next step is to determine a proper value for the residual amount purchased. This is the trickiest part and likely requires an expert analysis and valuation. Best practices would require that the taxpayer, sometime close to the time of purchase, take soil samples of the property to measure what fertilizer remains. And if you were particularly prepared, you would have secured information from the seller prior to closing regarding what, how much and where fertilizer was added to the land. An agronomist could then use that information, together with contemporaneous soil samples, to determine whether an identifiable residual supply remains and, if so, estimate its extent, value and expected exhaustion.

And that last point matters. The TAM did not merely ask whether the purchased soil was fertile. It focused on whether the taxpayer could identify fertility attributable to the prior owner's fertilizer and establish that the residual supply would actually decline through farming operations.

A farm may have exceptionally fertile soil because Mother Nature made it that way. But it is less clear whether Section 180 would allow a taxpayer to convert the inherent fertility of purchased land into a deductible asset simply by hiring someone to measure it. It is better for the buyer to establish that a measurable portion of the fertility being valued represents qualifying materials applied to the property and acquired as part of the transaction.

Absent that type of information, the next best option would be to have an agronomist test soil both on the property (in locations where the farming activity can actually take place) and compare them to soil samples from nearby properties where land is in an otherwise natural and unconditioned state. 

But as the baseline comparison grows or begins to include unreliable data points, your evidence of residual fertilizer begins to degrade and opens wider to attack from the IRS. Like all cases involving expert opinions, the devil is in the details. The inputs to the analysis along with how those inputs are construed become critical. And the TAM itself criticized the taxpayer's use of comparisons to similar parcels of land in the area "because of the variability of soil fertility in general". 

Another related point here is that these issues of the amount of residual fertilizer and its value can be negotiated with the seller. In fact, the IRS would prefer it that way. In other words, if Farmer Joe deducted the entire $300,000 cost of fertilizer but then sold his farm before it was all used and there was $200,000 left at the time of sale, there may be a matching and recapture issue. The buyer would prefer to deduct $200,000 of the total purchase price applicable to the residual fertilizer. But the seller would prefer to treat that as capital gain. The IRS would likely require that the treatment match. Indeed Pub 225, Farmer's Tax Guide, advises taxpayers of exactly that, stating, "If you sell farmland on which fertilizer or lime has been applied and if the selling price of the land includes part or all of the cost of the fertilizer or lime, you report the sale amount attributable to the fertilizer or lime as ordinary income." 

If the buyer is purchasing a farm as a going concern with assets and everything else, section 1060 may also require them to allocate the consideration among the acquired assets under the residual method and report that allocation on Form 8594. Under those circumstances, the purchase agreement is an obvious place for the parties to address the existence and agreed value of residual fertilizer or other qualifying soil-conditioning materials.

And doing so has several advantages. The seller can provide historical application records while those records are still readily available. The buyer can arrange for soil testing at or near closing. And the parties can negotiate the value assigned to the residual supply. Where the applicable reporting rules require consistency, both sides can report the transaction accordingly.

That contemporaneous evidence is considerably more persuasive than an allocation created after closing solely by the buyer. It may also save money. If reliable seller records, contemporaneous testing, and an arm's-length contractual allocation can narrow the factual dispute, the parties may avoid some of the cost involved in reconstructing the property's fertility history after the fact. 

Finally, taxpayers may need to be able to prove that the buyer is engaged in a farming activity and actually using or depleting the fertilizer. That sounds obvious, but it can be overlooked. 

In sum, there is nothing inherently improper about identifying a residual supply of fertilizer acquired with farmland, assigning value to it and deducting it. But neither the Code nor IRS guidance give taxpayers a clear roadmap for doing so.

The government guidance is remarkably thin: Section 180, two short regulations and an old technical advice memorandum. And the TAM itself does not expressly authorize the immediate Section 180 deduction that taxpayers increasingly claim.

That makes documentation particularly important. A strong file should establish, preferably with contemporaneous evidence, what the seller applied; where and when it was applied; what remained when the property was purchased; how much of the measured condition of the soil is attributable to those applications rather than naturally occurring fertility; what the residual material was worth; whether and over what period it will be exhausted; and whether the buyer is using the land in a qualifying farming business.

Could a taxpayer simply hire an appropriate professional, obtain a residual-fertility study and claim the deduction? Certainly.

But when the deduction turns a substantial portion of the purchase price of nondepreciable land into a current expense, one should expect the IRS to ask questions.

And when it does, a colorful soil map and a number at the bottom of a report are not nearly as compelling as a contemporaneous evidentiary record showing exactly what the taxpayer bought, why it qualifies, and how the value was determined.

At the end of the day, the deductions most likely to withstand scrutiny are those backed by a file full of support.

Leo Unzeitig of Chamberlain Hrdlicka

Shareholder

Leo Unzeitig is a shareholder in Chamberlain Hrdlicka's San Antonio office. He assists clients with a broad range of domestic and international tax... Read full bio

来源:Accounting Today(美国会计行业媒体) · accountingtoday.com

审计热点 是聚合摘要和阅读索引,原文版权归各来源所有,引用请以官方原文为准。如果你是来源方,希望更正、下架或调整展示方式,可以通过反馈页联系我们。

来自微信公众号的内容,本站仅呈现摘要与原文链接,不转载文章全文;文章权利归属原作者及原公众号

关于使用条款隐私信源